ࡱ> _ Ubjbj> > ;D\ci\ciC. . 8 ly4O"42O4O4O4O4O4O4O$QTXOXOmOFMp2OFl.KOY,RH*MO0O|HCUCUT.K.KCUBKlXOXOpOCU. Y : GUIDELINES FOR THE ASSESSMENT OF A DOCTORAL THESIS  ASSESSING A DOCTORAL THESIS BASIC Requirements FOR A DOCTORAL THESIS Requirements for this degree include the submission of a doctoral thesis. Such a thesis must make an original contribution to the body of knowledge in the particular discipline and must not have been submitted elsewhere for a formal qualification. The required length for a doctoral thesis is usually around 80000 words, with a leeway of 10%. ASSESSORS DUTIES The name of the assessor is not normally confidential but may be withheld from the student upon request. The supervisor and/or the non-assessing chair shares the contents of an assessors report with the candidate (anonymously if you have indicated that on the report form). Acceptance of the assessment task does not give the assessor the right to insist on a drastic change of the goals, focus or methodology of the study. If the assessor requires further information concerning the thesis, or needs to discuss any aspect of it, (s)he is encouraged to make contact with the non-assessing chair. Assessors may not request any colleague or other expert to assist in the evaluation of any part of the thesis. The assessment of the thesis includes an oral defence. This oral defence normally happens one to three weeks after all reports have been received from assessors. It is thus critical that we receive your report on the assessment timeously. Due to the global COVID-19 pandemic, the oral defence will take place online until further notice. More detailed information on the logistics around the oral defence will be communicated to you separately. 3. THE NARRATIVE REPORT Assessors shall report on the aspects of the candidate's work, with particular reference to the requirements spelt out below: 3.1 CONTENT AND RESEARCH METHODOLOGY Research methodology will vary considerably between disciplines. The following considerations may not be relevant in all instances, but as a guide, we ask assessors to consider: Delimitation of the field of study. Statement of aims on presentation of the problem to be resolved or investigated. Has the candidate demonstrated his/her mastery of research methodology and techniques? Are the findings a logical outcome of the analysis of the data? Is the general layout and flow of information (division into chapters etc.) logically structured? Has the candidate shown a capacity to use, evaluate and where necessary refute existing opinions in the field? Does he/she come to responsible conclusions that suggest satisfactory evidence-based personal insights in the field? Has the candidate scrupulously avoided plagiarism? 3.2 FORMAL ASPECTS Are the language (syntax, style etc.) and presentation (proof-reading, layout, use of appendices etc.) of a satisfactory standard? Is the citing and referencing done properly? Is the format and layout of the bibliography correct? Does the bibliography include the most important and recent sources? Is the overall impression of the presentation good? 3.3 OTHER ACADEMIC ASPECTS Are there any specific matters which, in your opinion, require correction, amendment or revision? (Please furnish details in your narrative report.) Is the thesis worthy of publication in part or as a whole or would it be after some minor repackaging or revision? Has the candidate made an original contribution to the body of knowledge in the particular discipline? (This is a prerequisite for a doctoral study.) FINAL EVALUATION As an assessor of a doctoral thesis you do not award a mark (grade), but instead are expected to recommend a final assessment outcome for the thesis on the Assessors Report form supplied to you. The final assessment outcome may be one of four recommendations, namely that you: 1. approve the thesis with or without minor editorial corrections; 2. approve the dissertation with minor corrections to be done to the satisfaction of the supervisor; 3. recommend substantial amendments to the thesis in the light of deficiencies identified in the narrative report and that the revised thesis be resubmitted for reassessment; 4. reject the thesis, in which case no reassessment is recommended or considered. If you have written any comments or made corrections in the assessment copy of the thesis, please return this copy to the Dean's Office together with the other documentation such as the Assessment Report Form and your narrative report. NB: If you wish to change or update your recommendation immediately after the oral defence (no longer than three days after the oral defence), and are happy to indicate as such in the oral defence, you must also fill in and sign SECTION E of the Assessors Report form. You may also submit an updated narrative report to the NAC and Faculty Officer. INTERNAL PROCESSES TO FINALISE THE ASSESSMENT In the event of different outcomes proposed by the assessors the necessary steps will be taken to resolve such a discrepancy as stipulated in the Higher Degrees Administration: Structures and Processes [with Additional Regulations for the Faculty of Humanities] policy document. The final decision on the assessment outcomes of a doctoral thesis is taken by the Senate Higher Degrees Committee. Thank you for your valuable contribution to our postgraduate assessment processes in the Faculty of Humanities at the ŷ100000 of Johannesburg.     PAGE  PAGE 2  PAGE \* MERGEFORMAT 2 23456AKQRSYeltq__M9'#h8Ph-25CJOJQJ^JaJ&h3oh3o5;CJOJQJ^JaJ#h8Ph8P5CJOJQJ^JaJ#hlRh-25CJOJQJ^JaJ#hlRh75CJOJQJ^JaJh3o5CJOJQJ^JaJ+hvyh3o5CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH .hvyh3o5CJOJQJ\^JaJmH sH jh9mUmHnHu+h *h3o5CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH 6h3o5CJOJQJ^JaJfHmH q sH 356RS|}  $^a$gd5[$ & F ,^,`a$gd8P $^a$gd-2 $ & F a$gd8P$a$gd8P$a$gd9m$a$gd3o $^a$gd3o $d@&a$gd3ot{|}- s t u ܯܓ~l~ZHZ~7 h* h-2CJOJQJ^JaJ"h!CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH "h* CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH "hCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h* h:SCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH h:SCJOJQJ^JaJh]9CJOJQJ^JaJ hlRhCJOJQJ^JaJhCJOJQJ^JaJhCJOJQJ^JaJ hlRh-2CJOJQJ^JaJ#hlRh-25CJOJQJ^JaJ   Q R S    , W tcRcA h|qh]9CJOJQJ^JaJ h|qh1\CJOJQJ^JaJ h|qh-2CJOJQJ^JaJ hlRh5[CJOJQJ^JaJh5[CJOJQJ^JaJh]9CJOJQJ^JaJ hlRh7CJOJQJ^JaJhCJOJQJ^JaJ hlRh-2CJOJQJ^JaJh1\5CJOJQJ^JaJ#hlRh75CJOJQJ^JaJh8PCJOJQJ^JaJW ^ f i m    0 C E F M R ޼seeWWhN1VCJOJQJ^JaJh1\CJOJQJ^JaJh|qCJOJQJ^JaJh"MCJOJQJ^JaJh5[CJOJQJ^JaJ hlRh7CJOJQJ^JaJh]9CJOJQJ^JaJ hlRh-2CJOJQJ^JaJ h|qh*0FCJOJQJ^JaJ h|qh]9CJOJQJ^JaJ h|qhCLCJOJQJ^JaJ    ! U W =IqӾmXCC(hD1hCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hD1hvCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hD1h;CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hD1hCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH "h9mCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hD1h!CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9m5CJOJQJ\^JaJmH sH .hD1hN1V5CJOJQJ\^JaJmH sH (hD1hN1VCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH qrstuvwx5vdOO9+h9bh8P5CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h3oh8PCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH "hCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH %h8P5CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH +hvyh8P5CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH  hlRh-2CJOJQJ^JaJ hlRh9mCJOJQJ^JaJh9mCJOJQJ^JaJh-2CJOJQJ^JaJh5[CJOJQJ^JaJ(hN1VhN1VCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH  rtuvwx56_$ & F p88^8a$gd8P $^a$gd $ @ a$gd* $^a$gd8P$0^`0a$gd8P$0^`0a$gd-2 $^a$gd-2 $^a$gdN1V56_wY=T[pqw5pZZE(hD}hCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH +h9bh8P5CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH "h8PCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bhCLCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bh]9CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bh"MCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bh8PCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bhCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bh* CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH _Y=pq5$0^`0a$gd-2$ & F p88^8a$gd8P$ & F p851$^5`a$gd $^a$gd$0^`0a$gd8P$ & F p88^8a$gd8P  ŶtbQ@Q+Q(hSh-2CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH  hShCLCJOJQJ^JaJ hSh-2CJOJQJ^JaJ#hD}h-25CJOJQJ^JaJh 5CJOJQJ^JaJ#hlRh-25CJOJQJ^JaJh8P5CJOJQJ^JaJ#hlRh"{5CJOJQJ^JaJh1\5CJOJQJ^JaJ hD}h-2CJOJQJ^JaJ(h9bh8PCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bh*0FCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH   q ua}$ & FnW^n`Wa$gd|q$0^`0a$gd|q$ & F p88^8a$gd|q$a$gdCL $ & Fa$gd8P$0^`0a$gd-2$ & F p88^8a$gdS$ & F p88^8a$gd*0F #Aop͸kVkVkVkAkVk(h9bh3oCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bhCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bhSCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hD}hSCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH #hlRh-25CJOJQJ^JaJ hD}h-2CJOJQJ^JaJ(hSh-2CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH  hSh8PCJOJQJ^JaJ hSh-2CJOJQJ^JaJ hSh"{CJOJQJ^JaJ q 45uAB`a%=Ffm[[[I"h!CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH "h9mCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hhf$-cCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hhtCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hN1VhSCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (htF"h5ICJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (htF"h|qCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bhCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bh|qCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH fgorAI֬tetS>)(htF"h3oCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (htF"h;CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH #hlRhS5CJOJQJ^JaJh5CJOJQJ^JaJhS5CJOJQJ^JaJ"hSCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH ,h9bhSCJOJPJQJ^JaJmH sH (h9bh|qCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hhgpCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hhtCJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (hhg`CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH a|}~& &`#$gd=gd=$a$gd;$ & F p88^8a$gdtF" $ & Fa$gdS$a$gdCL$ & FnW^n`Wa$gdIO%{|}~wweOO9O+h9bh;6CJ^JaJ+h9bh 6CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH +h9bh;6CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH "h;CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (h0dh;CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH h9bh;CJaJmH sH $htF"h^CJOJPJQJ^JaJ$hL h^CJOJPJQJ^JaJ(htF"h^CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (htF"h;CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH (htF"h CJOJQJ^JaJmH sH $%&'()/0123456MNOPQRSTUϳ|xh-2h ,jh9bh OJQJU^JmHnHuhNgOJQJ^JmHnHuh9bh OJQJ^J!jh9bh OJQJU^JhNg0JmHnHuhNh h0Jjh0JUh0jh0Uh=h=CJ^JaJ%&'(345QRSTUgd=$a$ &`#$gd=h]hgd= 9 0&P 1h:p|. A!"#$% Ddd  S 2A?Picture 1"bD.`a? DXn.`a?PNG  IHDRisRGBIDATx^}\Wu}L.j{ܻ MCS !|@ $|%1lqܛnZiN}|sڐKDv-3{?dUV(81d398b1!fw1L8r.(Iq ш"A .E"@V'g 76Qa A\, .1T cXhW,bP-"DDb"!K $fBV&dV@}]%F{-eBV+ t_I(%2?.Ƞ]9a&D˱ #@Dwą݉B+ .ˤABύ$k1G7_VD1P ᘫ+ˍRM, @&%C\]ꑑ@ҰQy Iuu:+K$BD](MG"R| qA4d+@y%H DD"-Q45puK.!HJr1 `O˄]ZgHP3eBXxV ](cD~m\] .!EEuu{oȢFirVb n#HN$^&$Vi Lˉ&˄ Lh[3r zᯮ0g9n..%'^uF1:do~B\NvO'{r+vF~B\?ٛ?#e;T Ѿ*4'(^a'-0 /&Dh3%ϻpYAb{%P'8I %fI 㛀h{1kI4P(F1p 3% ɻzCzА #)a."+qh|eQ\1%ѫgƒ =bkJIoX97qF1ӌ5ӜY=Xg1s$?PڐX)j500H %?",ղwK`-s1M<-%6˪.JrK `%,'y&  HbpQq$)!Z!#/MhĔH 2)?}qI|RD*pP@,RC'-0Iw~Eb=5Z_jOt& qn\DVxDgaOsD%bşz83Eb.ucLXca(+Z'!&d\X J,J!_Q2N֌@c27;)I1wn]E(j{> 0R 3[h0B L<7|63E`};;ʳ@Fd ƖYj!$J*#ya̕#.`<"+X?}qy;d'[n銙|bYWʹ!䄱 "-a\asa3Q?-_(qU'K$I d_Aݑ5VvC]7I3IpIU(JqlR:8S$O_$ QѤ ?A8 6BVB[bf`ViikW Mј(( syp~Aǚbױ|%􊬪"fƳR(P20Sl#KuZNex/dDlgT&0@+(≚-xkWTr*=D-"IIr@Xb>ct1jЪduLe) gn8a5]Qb}ƛ#&rLhSY@z yQzMKW"fi7Qe1=W,@@*%e*bHst] YOVUQUkNc@ĊY,"{Eajt@ 07,?QIL;1Ģ,kJu$%ҍPE1:c~YѫUeQAn'!14ABCtIx*ГN1R XQ ':0gES,2su#c_ڹt͠asWWLWϐŊ+ICm9Heg~:e)T7 ޳-^olmDUTCŕU"Vw =Φ@>,Czl0PҝsD#mR+u9ɵkS.a?}QҖXU򁚫8Q٪fr&Ԍ9NRRy@j^|W"B j/ Q$)5/?O+s]&nʮbIzICerʜ`P.tCvS)ɞV#1A#ltc6?m, SLobYJcZK JG=+]s+;FK5l'JU9+o 7UK_vuYa:4ƚ}]'C:7VJٵU KAc leIgFU34 U_|qI9^B+šQ\uiJǑR/WBy7[^|2)R TܮUk˙^9]REC#"S\sn9V.TC b qUŲkNfY}=Ru֝{kH7JaWR|aP0f]F6e޴M5obP6o Z{s9W|UZaؗ\VǓ׭/p9]/`9 ґ)H'ŋ2l׊* ʱ#^f/{;78Ĕ˨2!Yg^v[-FaSjX)BH*ߨ2J$3>3c>fʰU$zջ0,8"I+ܴʴ<6g]&ffYm<6TMAVQӁKa'b-MeqOyyť t^v8v6=xwwgp7[2"|ÁZMa`nc&pWM[V#]O8$p\7,74V驯EE/$bKx&{,4<_a5on_Ì qѪZ .j%M'?p闿?;y";Q kY|^rڹ/£% pF^bX.a_eKTqjE_xe&k_Fif GbhY0wwM_~.(#w0ō3htBbF6QѯT(CVfa0F `GҊ98XrUpα3g]Kngzʛ޳i6Hd`SHHЈH``qb`-N1^ HϪw}կgyٕH/l՛;X {ceԐ)փOHѕĶ=g,_}؇Oh  ?dOM[qRid$ }wdz./|+7mA$QC s ISʻqP E)Q*R 5>nm;x ZDYNb]3 V/~ū +f~a-]U*{ؒU;z /ie@7H8m9L2VYLWPsڶtGP5#df5.<LMAmjag󶗿Y^ *p$zY}L<[1Y£?V^HhxЀI S۾h,,Ω/,2zgQY-rp讦9Wa[~踊#79jm-b%Y6}  j^Szrhipzrzügbdؠ G=x7s}޽i2 H<S9υ"f403+2#$ @H*aG)Ci(UZor蓲O0;'{cN \J)[f͛leEî S Tp tX ,t}\t(996 NlIՠЙ,7yx][Sɝ36}SѬ"Wsv׵Y sÖ9\>ٱ9aس*3{ڵuƂmԠ`H>7wܰԴ衃ʳǠ2K%J'G<}.6Ћ"vkG,wKW5y իͳ@l(eೣؾoӒ65Yvdwy_Kzw$ąGWܠ4P>ΊaΑ͏mX|j` 3 a|*+f `KwbH`,o)OjìuxݭG^K)KSx͚yۮ].kZ} f^NIȢ.r'w}*шL03a^ Ob. Pw?3Kbut=zwxv[6t؉ZP4URNJ\8(Ԉ-'5 uՐCIqPQ*l w}| Iڌ@-okl_D 5"/<Co͞;geQAj߯ k6dBm']±=zRvC f sw<ۺl{g,Y$}ǻڏ8<'v%~}TbF- B2ͱ?;=|`Ҥ)6!n j*>,}!!oOy5 IFNӉpꈔgZOL' 'TtF8@!UyvBH}pkr:Je38xHgs^lCIR* 3ʵuc0s116p$ /JaĠc{,6tO`Օc}JA7ʔȎNf?@NJ!V#ڈ BB8AD>%層Z9KXc D 0'r $y¢@$%5U:ݜ`ʳ'$Y; NaUCZ>|׶zՑ;,7A١@Xv|]g[,N2NclL| o#!_,QDG̒첦BB\|:gSY? `绹ݗ~5}gFQ֭XsԆA%Nj]?Iƫ!"$S 0i^sʕc98,4G{r?EUuCC!X艀Kg$71|Ƨ#9Վkl P~dk8>!@bki: cL5mJVhPY$;{=[:zHҊܨժ盆0{՚sٴYHճc\$ ]8SaW(f$gm-{ѧ?ǚQ̄1jNt)ZCP25%w 7ցsA70X`x$WL>A# Gl9uXZ ~D )LpbIO{9QcA(#M0xeT\ZUe#=,bK[gmX}1t/`DhR1XlB<«ZKI{27O6DN?lWa :i1y=1{k?DFR,㢍C苩j2CfC[Ko}ëYqh?9v6+9eڂEW4+VW l)1-JiݏpDwc=0ӕK>%.ԓ ''x5)3:?OE Q ]$j2|Ssܻ%@E)4RU׽^:f1-9;+'s^Ic˵$R\To@ Gi px!t %څׇpÈ{CC'0Fm[֭Qs^Nza۪M}O=MU,8 (XCTxT 8dɼ1rWoc$Jv.Bٮ6}!$咡mHv1kI7xyVd!͘=F1{Ԇx-Oå;`phQpQ0Iv,yD'Dą#/?."]0Nf H.]3@˂QLb?;r؏p4ؽ@O\:AJ#\h]Ѧo!YDrPGҚ/z  ޚ`'G^;%W& ,BQPx]**$Wྋ)S|$!M-FR4OHi,9v5U:۶sLo?w3m2m7[%WUB }m~ms]:*8XUd)BkX2Yef/ԋU@vSͅ(,bji{_FZ4yǷ+  5ıPX3xX|IN@ZX]\<͓H``..A/d#BTÉEG5&<|6m_`)LiwQPXcABE`HX :qJ[Ž)vͲr6Fs$sd1OaݾCmk q]C//ǃJ8 }#9XsÄ VUhzL!fKS>Ҽs9% SHP5[%:C_(ZxT%Tq7\@6Vk$"T nɱlRAbYZ ںc XֳR{:՛l3hSU"@'Rm4 MC +*t%DHI`B!K ~Q)CK=Vb7 |,mT$Y 4$Aenzb6qB 25F nJo`\S2(D@92w6A~ U_;?v k +;yJ E#ẗ́p > kv*mIąI}@:Ztp2(}iWjPY˯E{| "#QF9TrxܟIt^V \ox4x$t=- ,7[*e-P xRxZQ8BrG.0Q~n☞#J ,nԡN@)Rȶg@#-%J j~>κ$&A`)DEǺJ%EI nhb $nL"6u[A)d) JJx$B#˼PU{d8H xx&g?h7u-./wV׳#EFePaw]L@yl:ܐPvLR\=Pʒ'-4S)>}V0Lt[qkVd2P z Uk-ߊ7ߑ*55ٶ,HV* Gh$xN[zzD`*S@Ày:TC&/DY[=0 1ORg8 >88;*! NbBS(@nGOO~jCݩOhtGeb"* Ц"ɝ'L%*=>O@(F@:шyWyϤb >I  _r:T;H" HKf69,tW;A3+S] k N-;<6Fl<ڿ#r/(Tg bCr7D*S# nќGIہD.pK\=({]QU6z(wvK]3Pm ~(PzByٗ, DF*ѯ" wT \?(R!RbɢSzJacpr/Y- ](u?&W(a Iw(kxPCA "} &>I@dC(aeHV !NO2BS$6_$]"/*pek[u:Lf'`%QIMa9FsЧ!K,@' W l(Z?UZ@k b PBA%pBȅ!34Lx!1&.lT$h~ŕT@Ozz!.p)wF 7ZAN".7Pk939rgk?sOrO2:w$(Jrx7&U<>zx5 .X0gȇ=o$H\$b4&B$7Q;L\#ZQhE\_lrӖJ?mPD,B 7;WR_'&k~B腥y@~ZdͬS|gw WTj8W. -8}|t/9@s@ɹW % %NznAG<8|~I_<*e5/|ޮ頪uTE Jx0I&3?tRSɯ_O o sk=AVsB"y> n\'Ꞹ+uΐC\֚I?:pg7ϓ 4z|$3r2k\07uR9%0̨z>rE{ jF` OuƾRBWݶDØ$D:@Au(Q-60 /YV4̊RTÿGje Cԋ %UM - !BǍ_:w=1)vc`6 (9Ň0<aCUr(ZNE?{~䣬G'dC!ϔ*%;A"ƌ+Erc]4;ܮrM 2fh*"36*H`Yp,}+ϲMOG+ 'y+/λƉH5Rb0[V{6 `iP݇-W4 q 3EԚq}"4:üԐd٪ٖ])RN+ Ϟoڶ{6<%y L_T@u^"UH`30Bkxr*tc{1& _sz SS<$'NX1TLv]Le2%uȡ9Qp$\ kDh@.4\I. ӣ+ь0v8 =(M{ˡǩ J2{~ãT6XӀGXRNƘ̄#./Jzn\44@HC' D( -{~}޿$vJrupO$g5͓Iރ>ZC Cʆ,F=&Nrf*Ԝq GN{ 8+d@ȤOzQ`SN_dw?|lݿR*#8rk \xg&gd#лH4 hYUN@eO:JgQyy7m~쉇 1C7tl~GL& %`PRњnŭO)#:0*89Jb3 8ޒMuƒUE1(<c &Ѿ-ೇ[aˊ1}| IT% <^z gdP =6n#g!񶸛0S00 Kj#UTM$IMmrI6O*6 ē\")UE=WA J4*~{mrMᝈk( hTؠ֘M]ss"H x~?2\tap3{xHv>䦚P-h","@Mv,E$ e,ob<NcVp\HKd 톭F*"t5:XXh4T#}OY{ ./.!ؑDbPC6}-Z1^x! nXYCXr[PШ(97b kevdﮇ{&UKґ]t(cEX0@\EJT(O+NXm3;ٻ>yKydPpM  Ln?D ܚIRΈNX3ZٳRP /;ŋ{&Ґi<# O֚*~ o-˖֕AQR'4RNr @+G)$%`!jL 0C;!pxTYh@tRm?~4U'eRGc%do# <MSʩ hIBUdr7`*iS-d{y!A9!c<.K,V$xA7GF1~J'~Żo$sTALR&2Bg4XuÛ?y2k8 (˵WC%mCRӪnz 벒EpHJ"z/r4-:gSb 𰜿`1V<@5JX*h.#Z|֧`nό4O| B\N{X=V6PEsJjRQ JCm`! J|4@ \<R({V@zōx?sxw_CpS@yGi/oLIjdӅԍVX٠U᫚Tx x]O% WY?Y+c0˺;8 tÃ=.jhÄX+ p\`cl*85c !X5_ݲB稭<]Ĉʛo+Z"`'w9k v57}=Oz}GIvӾ8ԽvpSL* C$C#7nݮ-3kԞzjͩ:%`P|=PH@V h] #936XFL o\%_ҞHPʴEoTJ@#GiّCU %`/ǩϻ(¬YTZ>=5 @~j}}B40{U2AVl25ev(+H"0t#t`0[z&``Lt-H#i!@۴˚f-9KTq텤(3w<>zls>r]PsI%x) $oAF(RJSmK?i6{MEZ +B;y-;LÇިU vFU+e ixS*Hޑq@i*]%Uϝ7|;A|8Ph/j<ɷOa"хLKJoGFG6o@@FQЇg~{!YP* HS|u-dNmy$8v`95jsCYaƲ$bˌYghm;jT͏ L&wZ܎hlgBSF?tHD q<^2FjM:h{p}, bee +3mMZRxO u) xN6yJĵd7C=ی]4!̼(Loܕ0$)R `|zG݊VD|" e9P{֟x鹺pr M)| 4JcZK 11qP&3Fc^RYĞ󯺪=Xsb LWbgPI t޷ #2AɊ<Ϳ75Ec?7MB cD]N/S $h#kh÷CDP-xz Ih.2rH+߲DM.*YGoJ|P4Qh/TA&(K22x$SoH* vٷ>fT'3"ABMEĘ@_ 00;fu8k-qÌHLSe^ʫ?y|DCy1PmKt 4e`Q#9}$~^S/=cċ'm&ąD_tVxOHe[ 'yc.(j [] W3#+QGJiR\mθ\ix -ݽRuS_4GC<!_z*pp4 JP΀uoy|/r}_%\r AqpDoc?n+7bGbK$R+p34N"KopCXfŠ>ǵ%'k详ZM-²)*KͫմشuŸN{"#O]O?.tv7ZPXh :ӯ{䠚1"ts:AD$ʜ;T/'.It@P%+e01SᖰR 8y37W:AɝdNh`H@'#TKOq0bC Dro~0\ mn5 C,T]W:yn;idE+JD\g2/E*Ҍ_b*wJ=/^X^d j\[ؼݽSϜv߯~9sY$. 6|ϾΈ fb.0"`5)}x߳U2f-:d۾_y}oH-IAֲȿ$PjJFc'1~'Gh<.|>d&2 r.D %2sCKH2p1G2Vrr0I=o㏾R h}Ci CX; dat 6ph_ڱٳJ{[G{Y[&@k7x'"J$r#c_p`(hȑ$."~p gq#L!P4He6?~nSMnAg$;#d2VeDNdd;$GT;9]خ͵#%sLc#8/KB[E\N@:Cs F6B=LB[۵쑑gcCGw{nVPL`9݈@'yia8'W?~*?puo/ZX)߄D>` I3&{τe9po]ky=yh3~^ᷱZ Mdn}uwfT40 ZI "^it(QAŒ ܴqCGlY`{J{v eVTl?M<`hGҨ I!Z(cY;&⋚c:]>Ղh۴&t'߭ٝ_ϰҷɱʦ;ډ,yM]\0?.}YeP"aaflu' [G|a&%S-'Bj @yGSjhZ :%xI^4!w%m&Cp< =T剐`x=6Sʎπ$;!%s +nP]oa::$މ Rd)etNNjHEm600 + JB`geŲm">Lt=T U ;qtS}pD6Q# I8L4R2 \DG`B1ˌ @ عЊ `US+QoBE 7CD{ G2)7>8.JU Z'A՘U}s+Q~ңАh7L.#`$> %:؅dدqdx@Ju&[R> 1 2&txp5kd^#> C2E8eh4JFrh,n&HHF>sRWHK | `4NWwQ6wIEӁ,@i/m5@6Dm*2xX|Ll6 YQ%ƛ@ף`g:&`k1Ԁ`4cPQ>#8 KHRZMTsCE=)r79.ڱ &qc} ]H vRqn@/By&yOi]FSuv4ːӤ$͕54dqUC8N'4?c킿fa$3nz\A4d]6$t̊ ^ė!(=D4H5G7h<3Q<t(iUfIF'UV4x` aS2 @AmҚLPO9Mĥ^t9'9~27Z-*bx)a0Crib^ iмd~eǂ0s_Ɩ\TM)Jib5a<39.ˊؘeY̚hF W>Fڀ!l0Ij 6{1•lRjH i6{-[|[-:OŶvf9}QMdsX!6mଦ@Ժ]>g>GKc/ԑGG6'̿+5W]s6'cUײM?qih8 遍3K-@#TCh/`@x*b"B`AБGñ.@mmb.R#TZ+Ӡ̚!hcV4&T꼋7GH̖S҈ 4v6Ml#mQkG]s5) ;j`axH9ڌ(ʅ^!55:{,ʙၦt{=ۤ-Zj̜~^4Үi\?X1"Lq⹜x2&y4GSDhMpE+F!K* UKN鞟~g]y1 Ode:4샲ZF:Cn V&Ƃ|JHr2XdUϟt|dKC-q&o'5L^4w@7 ں;pyku*+ qp*#G^;v:pShCA׾cA˩^Yc6S?cW07g7 x&*hH)8U#/_@2'л5EpHJ Ѭ0"J6!eh{ECI\5EN;uf+^7x07W2Y=52R-m{rA@LD |v;7K~e)o 0גf?r{ oy'ۻaë~,Hsg_jj.HCf"pUȇ|}]rF ~??t-ˁ[cl~r?LFn F0Xc`,$SP,0r `ۡѦl~{J^Ϧ5C &L{Q/.F4S"!\TV 2YhfM"83Yi"4*Cg^F Ijfg`ri:(ȹo}g cTtk%PmpI8T0 B1|jWJ77ZADђn0Ge 7[pɥP}+x) 1ѓQ4XͰ=肴&3zTkN`W^.4.LH煮 Euˋ/.|P*đBe2/4Ij8"zG~{'lo15(yt0D+(o 3P@D;c* 9p48O׿A (K96R$eq {vHs=o2嫱0 =[DjK\K5P%@CUJA&˒U@g^ wmq!it9JěFF/"ͪ0[)J2O!<㑴0|_m&]Y佫׳i)U5,v4s&7"f`Pg2<'4絀?`37M_P͎W4L想xk߉Lоm̪*r)1 ;c&F f yPqX1#2ZyQ<UӇ w VcT^K 9Z{ȤSKV,aő0| #.#f@};t.[m9ImZܺѐb&1<8|j. HEŋ#F-<Ҁ-A`lƆZ- їPԼA\vB@y"t>!둰 E t&&@Ȝڰ  b ]bMTuTK'"ȨWcÀB37,tR@3!%H0j WKHhIj:gJ{6B@BT`10xN*l|0^A~3aDp4}cGGWxQCAyʦBX8E3 J-,VJnoC*h$8@>B?x5mhZWp$r*"pYv0ZBrP1Fn  M  R4w=F3HAa>1A@ћ[%iEy$qIk1GT#IJ@:pO8*!(  P!,!p\;4/|XKEaא T67h5ol\0XDžϜ酹G"_op-@XpS# 16WK$!Ç٤H#A~ &.(N$%O&%Ѭ0C)B-r/fCD$,G!d "`=D&\1t(QFą&+p-&>aM`d(~uLa[܋wmܩi֕kWYI7n%h2JAxAL[ C{kz P< NxJO|@p 7j͜nAQ/L\X!vG%I.6z/u$4{j4 y-P A-hdL"ZSG r,U0"hh%K^(L67z Zhs 88< 1Z ׏WL[u{vo@m~vum۳HwjUZ81.T@bbBDJG^z,h&FǡW,7dCˡ<#~{X;43^ h#BH*;wxEV6~iqխV4$1>[C;x?}QU0p;5>!4}fj@T@!h4cݤTXBBT^I!`i8Ȓ[m *#셟%lXrsW^_ݱؕQ*VJS'R̍MOx*mIIs#oEBC Ї0H2E )>*{3䥈`>S16Jr"j2_Ca3/KU|{LKkn4ƈ"'J/E:HbQT!  4 0gTSP& eB `fǚQaX$*|t_lT:&fg~ÒS$ WW_r+F!8/PUёJ*&>'IŨ R_$Hs G#?(xDMtc [ 3q,"y7҆DI~FLBJE}$=6t+|uŅe-BnD @"A |R 7T& ߨƚ $P4i3i#M'#Q)+zqYBB-M3M (q3`RƏc r6J\,Ī?șPoL )5P|VGpp!_\I (ɖ&?okVd ;~/>5U6'ZrbYG`} >q6S!]Fآ {a %xEi ~꾇 %QlBOC-(ª|(JhE 9AǗG I5)8B|\pJ$8_|sl?F6TM@A FcQipkQ@@@QtH{q\p70Šs B /'OV| $R*1/x1[4=ӳ'r0sRo?ȡ&`4(EH2 4?SAm )J<3IZlB2M4W!6<]5$ "s>-.8څ9ո5洳ػō24=r&@<5,([.d,##z <>9(p8\ nHYv Jy#wx$@Ыiv9V23|P-!&&b;њ_ƶ"<| :*B ZkV3Vf,HQBMaޒ#E5#-Pv]+jZ\Uc$ /+WeHB hZ}QR5 =y%4eTnglQIkZ}Y8;={>m>]Ev9B6O/,Z)NZZ:5!ӌ;R*5q.T ߌ\7 cUe}{7=H6&Z.tYkJaʎqD.w>ūBM1 D}H,O5M?==GatRⲠgݵ~ctޱ8iV_fl>Yl`671g/n|F)y9 77?EaْK s/kP5oI-_ٰrIa|ڹ o|oWf-1,\0eڴcO=2dLd QǫnZ*E wt烙egs4,[:ytw8 h-T;y+旭jX0Τ37 fGd{o~C7?-ZF;`Э 0*Q+~6 Mx[>xӯiPl:νfxǛs7_W&mWΩ_PRQE,1p/qeTԖԎR) da߬4Ғ??7#-nA錕 ffA!An􂥤C: p "j53=;YL\ $PYQ=&Vh)[( %m)NXɦݼ iˇ Wx =_+B --EVXL [ vUtU*$kۓn"<J%W_xhx \']@D yp <[8?@i[xۑ:e^ ]J־Mg;N!r٠63Ddžf_zW6T{}k]A4*tY-yR^Hwv!ߨzmHEE-d!Inn;Z@jn 3T'F.* 4 72Պ]()/ F<HSyi9wU# p)RÅiξfx>E!@^lĭ eM=~ml^\x  JAB?.A1ëH<[y"PD f?ǯ9oȰ_o/?{AL!P3E_{A ܊_} s|Z3ӏiKq# ?`1Yf]u͸Wf (Q G7(ڷk[-bAw5lk_ۺtMYAs-,xW]vG?x?~;ѿ B[D Q`j>E HddV8W\|岋8:V~ :Mg O=(r}hX__KBcWdpǩCE\B]>-S+(W1x3jRJyY%p. J!R8T//ݱ}'pPZJFo]X0uz.^͉HCITJkJpE c9S-seeMZ w?uHΡ뾳e {r5SI{~ q?ra'P/8eu 7"*\^z-芇?JTb l]î}[˘ Ek|^\B] фzbYFGP>T6xUQͬ;Z%H,hF徾}Jݻ={Qaj})s+z%kϯ! CM~}+5׼"AM9efM@Q? S.ߔ,5@8?o#{,j)W'HOWR D??GJiSO7Y46 a_=R%Ƞ,ԦD|kwŊ]xaP6A+..`a~q%_uEG' 0:ED #;ҳC%B<scXdYj-k'YFYoFN6WؔBG<#odQ.W7. ʋߜ32-~n\d)dp 0l;OL/8g-s}7s7b^y\JPN)Aܽ˹붅׾ y`gF9C>ք=2Mp uu6L2k~C,l i 'M"Ҭ2d2Kqi1/_xYn͊gc^@[Sr]\^2tA Yl3O|_sbM4M+^oV*2SfՕvV=}&Zdw,̜BcEeW,g78U Vմv dJ8dYúeJ AOQ<=`abHh?ܦj)8x,+e0RCY㱚KGC:DY6q/=۩GPEHwb@J֫Z "P@g1z> ! ā~ZfƆKp՚;^"o40H *!K'*> ;XR;2M m8-*D9AQzT0Ŋys+ImT삫*2uƒb.p(tbEst#1m y "z̃?b yS x=a!Q pjL\):U[6 -)A$(8:ZN!PBAFV "U W4.Ҧi4אG"Q̊PQu{T%"x_:F4Pp4*ZoQEvॺhgt:o /{H$!V 1DiX:Z*e#I8H #W 8 .y3a$8|,*q 8E˚/MB2% AyCPȘCːu LoчL`H1ч7d7j7PݪQ%7h$YE$nDxh~^6O=~9PԆb•(f̹EpB=@Pdbf5rEyS 4Qv]T*4tL /BS B1Y±8}F"@%r?L&WQ54R\#8bKүx?Qz `oxF4n%Ebhͨpބh]Eӿ (d ޚD|3*VTKNp͠OLb r9Ce $2@TT>]TvA[2G#;t _DVz)D 5._lԩ 5ޟHˏD4 _J'ú꓂:_q3 G$ORJ3W\*gXRGGIx!-_,M%1⦑0\ (8IB-OQQƈGN P$RgxwgBsIvAL~N ޒ# BC58,R!TYM"NO862N~.ud&F'X(:M, GЊPH^ꩧWCEIw$6EwNK UI}qE A97kж:4•ՇD0 c٣:;/N $5G3D# p Bd!Uoz>- A]:@rH~N.I&ִ$+l_@! LzG ڈ\C#D"(wǫ`\\24۔$::twA%uo7aJGMF$) /t$f>bD$L^M[?4a"{Ί1ڄ߇䃛$󶦤KG.pHP-4 {z#/65wx#0 z"zjEîMf<$%/a҄FH= u^\Hs5=3P rIt=ԂE' 3{ 8"o-Lm8oBA0z#MA}g“HK8%\$-T6&L3n8!Ye󏣽n 0 J@퇘G䡍!''P**_VACИ )'2nW84D>>i0/S #9O>-ⱷS#(G45^F<%7@ܤ ~ĒLkAK'V QP8RcnS]ꇘ@QHz$9T=Rn5|8<;PoD_[&v$3PfR\)Op;>?Ϲ̓·%+<[&?oN]:סN9~5<JVC]''__gE-(s{@\ġMZ2Nt%퉈k$9t}K'.3*7cC('?۳DˣÕx|?Dm=MYW~I]> Gݥl^;YUWdǤ?t gEmLp5B&pRfzlQ)Idnp%ٱx͸ԌN'^Zq1F/ؓX q9Śx鄸LIbMtB\&d$V`B\Nb&^ZSg4+0.x?:ompr?!.'^g'  q9:_=!.g= "UIENDB`x02&6FVfv2(&6FVfv&6FVfv&6FVfv&6FVfv&6FVfv&6FVfv8XV~ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@ 0@66666_HmH nH sH tH 8`8 -2Normal_HmH sH tH DA D Default Paragraph FontRiR 0 Table Normal4 l4a (k ( 0No List 4 @4 =0Footer !:)`: @C Page Number CJOJQJ4@4 =Header !~"~ _^(Style Justified Line spacing: 1.5 lines dha$mH sH H2H lR Balloon TextCJOJQJ^JaJ:/A:  0 Footer Char mH sH tH B' QB N1VComment ReferenceCJaJ4b4 N1V Comment TextF/qF N1VComment Text Char mH sH tH @jab@ N1VComment Subject5\R/R N1VComment Subject Char5\mH sH tH PK![Content_Types].xmlN0EH-J@%ǎǢ|ș$زULTB l,3;rØJB+$G]7O٭V (BO)MBT.$@0H!A>풠Uc-zD[&!rX=}zC0` ި%.]Ssd--7 +fOZեrŵVœ\lji2ZGwm-3˵j7\ Uk5FҨ-:xRkcr3Ϣ+9kji9OP Et-j|#p;E=Ɖ5Z2sgF=8 K}*7c<`*HJTcB<{Jc]\ Ҡk=ti"MGfIw&9ql> $>HmPd{(6%z:"'/f7w0qBcF6f Iöi1(\}B5ҹ~Bcr6I;}mY/lIz1!) ac 1fm ƪN^I77yrJ'd$s<{uC>== Ƌ(uX=WA NC2>GK<(C,ݖm: &-8j^N܀ݑ$4:/x vTu>*ٞn{M.Ǿ0v4<1>&ⶏVn.B>1CḑOk!#;Ҍ}$pQ˙y')fY?u \$/1d8*ZI$G#d\,{uk<$:lWV j^ZơSc*+ESa1똀 k3Ģxzjv3,jZU3@jWu;z \v5i?{8&==ϘNX1?  O4׹ӧCvHa01 %xz24ĥ=m X\(7Xjg !Ӆqd? cG7.`~w*?, 2 nN*"Fz_&n &\ F:l[+%f U3D $$BBBEt W q5fIU  _a&U!  $<>E!!!L# @0(  B S  ?SV-+ U a Z o  epSV3333333333334RR=Isv%%(25PV=Isv%Vl/#`&;f*-  ::# u&94?v)61RHEI iLDM iutRJ5lrogP=knZna*jo*%6[p^d|+^`o(.^`.pLp^p`L.@ @ ^@ `.^`.L^`L.^`.^`.PLP^P`L. ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(pp^p`OJQJ^Jo(o @ @ ^@ `OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(PP^P`OJQJ^Jo(o   ^ `OJQJo(^`5o(.^`.pLp^p`L.@ @ ^@ `.^`.L^`L.^`.^`.PLP^P`L. ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo(^`5o(.^`.pLp^p`L.@ @ ^@ `.^`.L^`L.^`.^`.PLP^P`L. ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o p^p`OJQJo( @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o P^P`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo(^`o(.^`.pLp^p`L.@ @ ^@ `.^`.L^`L.^`.^`.PLP^P`L. ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo(^`o(.^`.pLp^p`L.@ @ ^@ `.^`.L^`L.^`.^`.PLP^P`L. ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(pp^p`OJQJ^Jo(o @ @ ^@ `OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(PP^P`OJQJ^Jo(o   ^ `OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o pp^p`OJQJo( @ @ ^@ `OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o PP^P`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo( ^ `OJQJ^Jo(o  ^ `OJQJo( x^x`OJQJo(H^H`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo( ^`OJQJo(^`OJQJ^Jo(o ^`OJQJo(f:# iLZn6[p`jorog DM1utR?v)=kl/HE u&^d|                           n}                                   ( >                                                                                                  >9ml )8PkJ9o L p F4 9NgCL> 7Pc*}.^47]9|@AC @CfC)YE*0FPGI wKN NK QS:STN1V~Y@ TI5IkJ[^^f$-cd)Yd0de!z__Grammarly_42____i__Grammarly_42___14H4sIAAAAAAAEAKtWckksSQxILCpxzi/NK1GyMqwFAAEhoTITAAAATH4sIAAAAAAAEAKtWcslP9kxRslIyNDYyMzU2MzI1t7A0NTQws7RQ0lEKTi0uzszPAykwrAUAgwbeQCwAAAA=@   U0@Unknown G.[x Times New Roman5Symbol3. .[x Arial5. .[`)TahomaC. Aptos Display3. Aptos?= .Cx Courier New;WingdingsA$BCambria Math"h8j׃ŇQf$ &$ &!d20C@P  ?-2!xx, 7Guidelines for the Assessment of a Doctoral Thesis 2014sjj Jordaan, ReneT             Oh+'0  $0 P \ h t8Guidelines for the Assessment of a Doctoral Thesis 2014sjjNormalJordaan, Rene4Microsoft Office Word@Ik@~<@@G@R<,$ ՜.+,D՜.+,|8 hp  ŷ100000 of Johannesburg&  8Guidelines for the Assessment of a Doctoral Thesis 2014 TitleP X!)5AY}5 A UJ_FacultyUJ_DepartmentUJ_Document_Author _dlc_DocId_dlc_DocIdItemGuid_dlc_DocIdUrlPublishingExpirationDate PublishingStartDateAandre WesselsUDSYSTPJJFXM-959595718-33(b804d168-04b4-4418-ae43-afec4df80b05/faculties/humanities/_layouts/15/DocIdRedir.aspx?ID=UDSYSTPJJFXM-959595718-33, UDSYSTPJJFXM-959595718-33  !"$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdeghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry FY, Data #1TablefUWordDocument;DSummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8MsoDataStore p>X,OY,0LVWJUIORJFO==2p>X,X,Item  PropertiesS2VNE0EMTSP5==2 p>X,Y,Item  Properties OS0SWJPT1B==2p>X,OY,Item -Properties}  !"#% DocumentLibraryFormDocumentLibraryFormDocumentLibraryForm This value indicates the number of saves or revisions. The application is responsible for updating this value after each revision. metaAttributes"/>  F Microsoft Word 97-2003 Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89qCompObj$r